Individual and Business
Insurance Solutions

Protection for your Business Health Family Parents

Colangelo Group is your go-to Westchester, NY Independent Insurance agency. We compare carriers to get the best plan for you.
Family Protection
Individual Protection
Retirement Planning
Next Generation
5 stars business insurance rating in new york

Our verified customers have rated us 5 out of 5.

We value feedback from our clients. Leave us a review on Google!

Independent Insurance Agency in New Rochelle, New York

We’re a one-stop insurance agency located in New Rochelle, New York. You can easily get a free quote for your individual or business insurance needs. Contact us now to schedule a free consultation with one of our independent insurance specialists, either by phone or in-person. It’s fast, easy, and free!

Individual and Business Insurance

Services Tailored To You:

Business Insurance

Speak with a business insurance advisor today to help you choose the right protection for your business.

Employee Benefits

Business owners need a partner to simplify the complex world of health insurance and employee benefits.

Commercial Liability Insurance

Get coverage that helps protect you and your property.

life insurance medicare independent agency
Medicare and Long-term Planning Solutions

Secure your retirement assets, while preserving your long-term planning choices and peace of mind.

contractor and performance and payment bonds insurance new rochelle ny
Contractor Performance and Payment Bonds

We help business owners like you increase their bonding lines and get the jobs they want.

new york small business health insurance
Home Insurance

Our team will help you understand your policy and find the right home insurance coverage for you.

auto-insurance-commercial-auto-new rochelle-ny
Auto Insurance

Dedicated to protecting you and your vehicle

A local independent insurance agency with a national network.
Some of our trusted partners:

empire blue cross blue shield logo
aetna logo
united healthcare logo
wellcare logo

Why Choose Colangelo Group


Choose Colangelo Group for 20+ years of experience, reliable product selection, and fast, friendly customer service at a lower price. Trust us for personalized insurance solutions to protect what matters most.

Locally Owned

Choose Colangelo Group for our local presence in New Rochelle and Westchester County, offering in-person or online appointments. Trust us to serve and protect our community with personalized insurance solutions.

we are independent

That means we can offer you more choices and access to the best plans and pricing.

Custom Solutions

All of your insurance needs in one place. With personalized attention and competitive rates.

customer reviews

The Colangelo Group made the process of getting health and dental insurance easier than anything I've ever experienced! I work in the healthcare field and realize both professionally and personally just how difficult and confusing the world of health care can be. I HIGHLY recommend The Colangelo group to individuals, families or corporations. They are professional, responsive and make you feel 'cared for'.
S. M
“Rob Colangelo was knowledeable and personable with my health insurance choice. I have recommended Colangelo Group to others in determining their health insurance needs”
John D.
"My company changed insurance brokers three years ago. Since switching over to the Colangelo group we have lowered our premiums and have better coverages. We have been very happy with the attentive service, and happier with Robert & Lisa saving us money!"
J. D.